AMERICA'S CHOICE Spice Drops Gumdrops usually come in two kinds: assorted fruit flavors and assorted spice flavors. A & P's house brand of spice-flavored drops has two surprises. While most of the colors correspond to familiar spice flavors, the flavor of the orange-colored drops is Mentholated Orange, and the flavor of the yellow drops is Heavily Mentholated Lemon. These yellow gumdrops are probably the worst commercial gumdrops in the U.S., and certainly the most preposterous "spice drops"! 2000-08-11.