Pentacube Odd Cakes

Introduction

An oddity is an arrangement of an odd number of copies of a polyform to make a figure with even symmetry. See Polyform Oddities.

Pentominoes can form oddities with any even symmetry up to full symmetry, the 8-fold symmetry of a square. For example, Mike Reid arranged 13 copies of the P pentomino to make this oddity with square symmetry:

No oddities with square symmetry are known for pentominoes T, U, and V.

A pentacube is a solid made of five cubes joined face to face. There are 23 pentacubes, not distinguishing mirror images:

Define a polycube cake as an arrangement of one or more copies of a polycube to form a prism whose base is a polyomino with full (square) symmetry. Here is an example of a cake for the J pentacube:

It is easy to construct a cake for each pentacube. In the following section, for each pentacube I show a smallest known cake with an odd number of tiles. Even though pentominoes T, U, and V have no known full-symmetry oddities, the corresponding pentacubes have odd cakes.

If you find a smaller odd cake for a pentacube or solve an unsolved case, please write.

See also Polycube Oddities.

Table

This table gives the number of tiles in the smallest known odd cake for each pentacube.

ABEFGHIJKL MNPQRSTUVWXYZ
?332521?371154515? 2592146554057527332912173

Tilings

In these tilings, the tiles are not reflected.

Pentacubes I and X are odd cakes in their own right.

The minimal known odd cakes for pentacubes F, W, X, and Z are pancakes, flat cakes. They are minimal known full-symmetry oddities for the corresponding pentominoes. See Pentomino Oddities.

A

None known.

B

E

F

G

None known.

H

I

J

K

L

M

None known. In fact, no odd prism at all is known for the M pentacube.

N

P

Q

R

Mike Reid found that pentacube R can tile the odd box 5×7×19. His tiling is not known. But it shows that 4655 copies of this pentacube can tile a square box 35×35×19. A square box is a special case of a cake.

S

T

U

V

W

X

Y

Z

Last revised 2026-09-22.


Back to Polycube and Polykedge Tiling < Polyform Tiling < Polyform Curiosities
Col. George Sicherman [ HOME | MAIL ]